Where to live · Pennsylvania

Erie, PA

The City of Erie publishes a 2% realty transfer tax on a sale inside the city — 1% shared by the City and the Erie School District, 1% to the Commonwealth — and Pennsylvania makes buyer and seller jointly and severally liable for it regardless of what the contract says about who pays.

Two things decide what the realty transfer tax means at an Erie closing. The first is the amount, and the City publishes it: "2% Realty Transfer Tax is levied on the sale or transfer of Real Estate within the City of Erie. 1% is shared by the City of Erie and Erie School District and the other 1% goes to the Commonwealth." The second is liability, which is a different question from who writes the cheque: the Commonwealth holds grantor and grantee jointly and severally liable, and the regulation provides that the duty "may be discharged by the parties as they agree but without prejudice to the rights of the Commonwealth against the parties." This page sets out the City's published figure, the ordinance provision that explains why the local share is one percent shared rather than one percent each, and which transfers are excluded.

Short version: The City of Erie publishes the total: 2 percent on a sale inside the city, of which 1 percent is shared by the City and the Erie School District and 1 percent goes to the Commonwealth. It is not 3 percent, because the City’s ordinance halves its own rate automatically when another taxing body reaches the same transfer. And Pennsylvania holds both buyer and seller jointly and severally liable — a contract allocating the cost binds the parties, not the Commonwealth.

Liability and payment are two different questions

This is the distinction worth carrying into a negotiation, because conflating the two is how people end up exposed on a deal that has already closed.

Who is liable. The Department of Revenue states it plainly: “Both grantor and grantee are held jointly and severally liable for payment of the tax.” The regulation puts the same duty on both sides of the document — under 61 Pa. Code § 91.111(a) the 1 percent State tax falls on the person who delivers a document for recording and the person who accepts or presents it.

Who pays. That is a matter of agreement, and the regulation says so expressly:

“it is the joint and several legal duty of the parties to the transaction to pay the proper tax due. This duty may be discharged by the parties as they agree but without prejudice to the rights of the Commonwealth against the parties.”

Read the last clause carefully. A contract term saying the seller pays the transfer tax is perfectly effective between buyer and seller. It does not narrow who the Commonwealth may pursue. “Joint and several” means the Commonwealth can look to either party for the whole amount, and the agreement is then a matter for the parties to sort out between themselves.

The practical consequence is small in a clean transaction and real in a messy one: the allocation is a commercial term, not a transfer of legal liability.

The amount: 2 percent, and why it is not 3

The City of Erie Treasurer’s Office publishes the figure plainly:

“2% Realty Transfer Tax is levied on the sale or transfer of Real Estate within the City of Erie. 1% is shared by the City of Erie and Erie School District and the other 1% goes to the Commonwealth. The tax is paid when the deed is filed with the Recorder of Deeds, located in the Erie County Court House.”

That is worth reading twice, because the obvious arithmetic gives a different answer. Pennsylvania charges 1 percent. The City of Erie’s own ordinance imposes “a tax at the rate of 1% of the value of the real estate represented by such document.” The Erie School District reaches the same transfers. Added up, that looks like 3 percent.

It is 2, and the ordinance itself explains why. Section 373.02(c):

“It is the intent of this article that the entire burden of the tax imposed herein on a person or transfer shall not exceed the limitations prescribed in The Local Tax Enabling Act … so that if any other political subdivision shall impose or hereafter shall impose such tax on the same person or transfer then the tax levied by the City under the authority of that Act shall during the time such duplication of the tax exists, except as hereinafter otherwise provided, be 1/2 of the rate and such 1/2 rate shall become effective without any action on the part of the City”

With an alternative: the City and the other subdivision “may agree that, instead of limiting their respective rates to 1/2 of the rate herein provided, they will impose respectively different rates, the total of which shall not exceed the maximum rate permitted under ‘The Local Tax Enabling Act’.”

So the local burden is capped and apportioned, not additive — the City’s percentage operates at half because the school district reaches the same transfer, and the reduction takes effect automatically, “without any action on the part of the City.” The City Treasurer’s published split is that provision working: one percent of local tax, shared between two bodies.

How far that local component can vary elsewhere is worth knowing if your search is not confined to Erie. Allegheny County publishes a rate for every municipality within it, and they are not uniform — most are 2% with the Commonwealth’s share, Bethel Park is 2.5%, and the City of Pittsburgh reaches 4.5% or 5% depending on its school district. See Bethel Park for that table and what it means for cash to close.

Where the figure comes from

Element Position
Total, inside the city 2% of value
Commonwealth’s share 1%
City and school district 1%, shared between them
Liability Grantor and grantee, jointly and severally
Collected by Erie County Recorder of Deeds

Two scoping points on that 2 percent. It is the City’s statement for real estate “within the City of Erie” — surrounding municipalities and their school districts levy under their own ordinances at their own rates, so a transfer in a neighbouring township is a separate question. And it is a percentage, not a dollar figure: the amount depends on the value of the specific property, and no estimate has been calculated here from any area average.

The figure for a specific deed is confirmed by the Erie County Recorder of Deeds, which the Treasurer notes is “authorized by law to be the collection agent for both state and local realty transfer taxes”, with “two percent of the amount collected … withheld to reimburse the county for cost of collection.” Your closing agent will have it; asking for it in writing early is better than estimating it late.

One timing point: the tax is “payable at the earlier of the time the document is presented for recording or within 30 days of acceptance of such document.”

And a note on value, which is not always the contract price. The state tax applies to the value of real estate “including contracted-for improvements to property” — relevant on new construction, where an executory construction agreement can form part of the taxable value.

When a parcel sits in more than one municipality

An Erie-area possibility worth knowing about. Section 373.10(b) requires that “In order to ascertain the amount of taxes due when the property is located in more than one political subdivision, the Recorder shall not accept for recording such a deed unless it is accompanied by a statement of value showing what taxes are due each municipality.”

A parcel straddling a boundary is therefore a recording issue as well as a tax one, and it is better identified during title work than at the recording desk.

Transfers that are excluded

Article 373 lists a long schedule of exclusions. The ones most likely to come up:

  • Family transfers — § 373.04(f) excludes transfers between husband and wife; between people previously married to each other who have since divorced, where the property was acquired before the final decree; between parent and child or the spouse of that child; between siblings or a sibling’s spouse; and between grandparent and grandchild or that grandchild’s spouse. With a clawback: “a subsequent transfer by the grantee within one year shall be subject to tax as if the grantor were making such transfer.”
  • Deed in lieu, and the mortgage holder’s bid — § 373.04(p) excludes a transfer by a mortgagor to the holder of a bona fide mortgage in default in lieu of foreclosure, and a judicial sale where the successful bidder is the bona fide mortgage holder, “unless the holder assigns the bid to another person.”
  • Correcting deeds — a transfer for no or nominal consideration that “corrects or confirms a transfer previously recorded, but which does not extend or limit existing record legal title or interest.”
  • Trivial amounts — § 373.04(v) excludes a transaction “wherein the tax due is $1 or less.”
  • Government bodies — exempt under § 373.03, but with the sting noted below.

To claim an exclusion, “the true, full and complete value of the transfer shall be shown on the statement of value.” Section 373.11 exempts transfers excludable “based on family relationship” from that requirement.

If you are buying from a relative, the financing has its own considerations beyond the tax — see buying a home from a family member.

Two traps worth naming

A government body’s exemption does not cover you. Section 373.03 exempts the United States, the Commonwealth and their instrumentalities, agencies and political subdivisions — then adds: “The exemption of such governmental bodies shall not, however, relieve any other party to a transaction from liability for the tax.” Buying from a public body is not a tax-free transaction for the buyer.

At a judicial sale, a shortfall lands on the purchaser. Section 373.09 gives the tax priority out of the sale proceeds ahead of other claims except the state tax, and provides that “If the proceeds of the sale are insufficient to pay the entire tax herein imposed, the purchaser shall be liable for the remaining tax.”

If it is underpaid

The City authorises the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue to determine, collect and enforce the tax, interest and penalties, with interest at 10% per annum. Under § 373.13 the assessment window is three years from recording, extending to six years “If the taxpayer underpays the correct amount of the tax by 25% or more”, and running without limit where part of the underpayment is due to fraud or “an undisclosed, intentional disregard of rules and regulations”. Section 373.12 adds a 50% addition where an underpayment is due to fraud.

One credit worth knowing if you are buying new construction from a builder who took your old house in trade: § 373.07(b) gives the builder a credit for the tax paid on that trade-in, where it occurred within the preceding year, against the tax due on the sale of the new, previously unoccupied home.

Negotiating it

Since § 91.111(b) contemplates the parties discharging the duty “as they agree”, who bears the transfer tax is a negotiable term like any other closing cost. It is worth considering alongside the other levers, because a seller contribution toward costs and a reduction in purchase price do not have the same effect on a loan — see seller credits versus price reductions.

The other Erie taxes, and the escrow point

Transfer tax is a one-off at closing. The recurring bill comes from somewhere else, and the Treasurer sets out the structure: “There are three taxing districts; The City of Erie, Erie County, and the Erie School District.” The City “imposes a tax on all real estate in the City”, and “The Erie County Assessment Bureau determines the value of the property on which taxes must be paid.”

The three run on different calendars, which matters for a first-year budget:

Bill Due Discount
City Calendar year 2% by end of March
County 30 June 2% by last day of April
School 30 November 2% by end of September

City and County bills are “generally sent out annually by the end of January for the current year together in one envelope”, while School bills go out “by then end of July”. Treat those discount dates as the standing rule rather than a fixture: the Treasurer records that “Due to the delay in the 2025 County Real Estate Taxes, the City has extended the 2% discount due date until the last day of April 2025”, so the City has moved its own date at least once. Check the date printed on the bill you actually receive. A 10% penalty attaches to City and School tax paid after their due dates, and taxes still unpaid on 1 January are “turned over to the Tax Claim Bureau of Erie County”, where interest runs at “.75% per month or 9% per annum”.

One operational note for anyone with a mortgage, in the Treasurer’s own words: “If you have a mortgage and your property taxes are escrowed, your tax bill should be mailed by you, to your mortgage company for payment from your escrow fund.” The City sends the bill to the homeowner, not the servicer — “We are required to send all tax bills to the homeowner of the property. If your mortgage company requires a copy of the bill for payment, it is your responsibility to forward the tax bills to them.” That is a genuine action item in the first year of ownership, and missing it is how an escrowed account ends up with an unpaid bill.

Financing in Erie County

Erie County sits in PHFA’s Region 6, with a Keystone Home Loan purchase price limit of $499,900 and income limits of $106,000 for one- and two-member households and $121,900 for three or more. Erie is not one of PHFA’s Target counties — but twenty Erie County census tracts are listed as designated targeted areas, where the first-time buyer requirement is waived: 0001, 0003, 0004, 0005, 0006, 0007, 0008, 0009, 0010 (block groups 1–3), 0011 (block group 1), 0012, 0013, 0014, 0015, 0017, 0018, 0019, 0020, 0023 (block group 4) and 0028 (block group 4). A discharged veteran is exempt from the requirement anywhere.

That is a large number of targeted tracts for one county, and it is the sort of thing worth checking by address before assuming a prior home purchase rules you out. How the PHFA tests work is on Allentown.

The city these rules land in

Erie’s population was 91,838 at the most recent Census Bureau estimate, down 3.3% since the 2020 Census, across 39,848 households in 19.14 square miles. Owner-occupancy is 54.1% — the highest of the four Pennsylvania cities covered in this round — with a median owner-occupied home value of $115,200, the lowest of the four, and median monthly owner costs with a mortgage of $1,139. Median household income is $46,113, and 23.3% of residents are below the poverty line.

Those are Census Bureau city-wide figures and they are context only. In particular, no transfer tax figure has been calculated from the median home value on this page: transfer tax is a function of the value of the specific property being conveyed, and a citywide median is not a substitute for it.

A note on the data: QuickFacts returned the “X” flag — not applicable — for Housing Units and Building Permits for Erie. That is an absence of an applicable figure in that table rather than a zero, and nothing has been inferred from it.

What this page cannot tell you

  • The dollar amount on your closing statement. The City publishes the 2 percent rate for transfers inside the city, but the amount is a function of the value of your specific property, and a transfer outside the city limits runs on that municipality’s own ordinance. The Recorder of Deeds confirms the figure for the actual deed.
  • Whether a particular exclusion applies to your transfer. The schedule is detailed and conditional, and that is a question for your closing agent or attorney.
  • What the taxable value of your transaction is, where contracted-for improvements or a non-arm’s-length transfer are involved.

What it should do is make sure nobody tells you the transfer tax is “the seller’s problem” and leaves it there, and that nobody estimates it by adding up percentages. If you want the cash-to-close side worked through properly, see Pennsylvania mortgage options.

Is Erie a fit?

Who Erie may fit

Buyers and sellers at an Erie closing who want to know who is legally on the hook for the transfer tax, what it is likely to be, and which transfers are excluded.

Who may prefer elsewhere

Buyers whose question is about the annual property tax bill rather than the one-off closing cost should read Harrisburg for the statewide homestead exclusion; buyers in Philadelphia should read that page for the City's abatements and its separate Homestead Exemption.

Nearby cities to compare
Market snapshot

Erie housing market

Live market data (median price, inventory, days on market) connects here once a verified source is wired for erie-pa. No figures are shown until then.

Financing · Hero Mortgage Group

Found the place? Now build the financing plan.

Hero Mortgage Group is a firefighter-owned brokerage licensed in Pennsylvania, working remotely from Florida. Transfer tax is a cash-at-closing item rather than a qualifying one, but it is worth pinning down early — the Recorder of Deeds can confirm the figure for the specific parcel, and knowing it beats estimating it.

Hero Relocation Plan

Not ready to buy yet? Build your Hero Relocation Plan.

You don’t have to be ready today. Tell us where you’re considering, when, and what matters to your family — we’ll help you organize the next steps at your pace.

Start planning your move →

Educational, no-pressure. This is planning help toward a future move — not a sales call.

Sources
Common questions

Erie — straight answers

Who pays the realty transfer tax in Pennsylvania — the buyer or the seller?
Legally, both. The Department of Revenue states that "Both grantor and grantee are held jointly and severally liable for payment of the tax." Who actually writes the cheque is a matter of agreement: 61 Pa. Code § 91.111(b) provides that the joint and several duty "may be discharged by the parties as they agree but without prejudice to the rights of the Commonwealth against the parties." So a contract splitting the cost is binding between buyer and seller, but it does not limit whom the Commonwealth can pursue if the tax goes unpaid.
What is the Pennsylvania state rate?
One percent. The Department of Revenue states the tax "is imposed at a rate of 1 percent on the value of real estate (including contracted-for improvements to property) transferred by deed, instrument, long-term lease or other writing." Note that contracted-for improvements can form part of the value, which matters on new construction.
Does the City of Erie charge its own transfer tax on top?
Yes, but it does not stack the way the published rates suggest. The City imposes a local tax under Article 373 of its Codified Ordinances at "a tax at the rate of 1% of the value of the real estate represented by such document" — while the City Treasurer's Office publishes the real-world outcome as "2% Realty Transfer Tax ... 1% is shared by the City of Erie and Erie School District and the other 1% goes to the Commonwealth." The ordinance explains why those are consistent: § 373.02(c) provides that if another political subdivision imposes the same tax on the same transfer, the City's rate "shall during the time such duplication of the tax exists ... be 1/2 of the rate and such 1/2 rate shall become effective without any action on the part of the City" — unless the City and that subdivision agree on different rates whose total does not exceed the cap in the Local Tax Enabling Act.
So what is the total transfer tax on an Erie closing?
The City of Erie publishes it directly: "2% Realty Transfer Tax is levied on the sale or transfer of Real Estate within the City of Erie. 1% is shared by the City of Erie and Erie School District and the other 1% goes to the Commonwealth. The tax is paid when the deed is filed with the Recorder of Deeds, located in the Erie County Court House." So on a sale inside the city the total is 2 percent — not the 3 percent you would get by adding the Commonwealth's 1 percent to a full 1 percent each for the City and the school district. That 2 percent figure is the City's statement for property within the city limits; a transfer in a surrounding municipality is governed by that municipality's and school district's own ordinances, so confirm the figure for the actual parcel with the Erie County Recorder of Deeds.
Who collects it, and when is it due?
The county Recorder of Deeds. The Department of Revenue states that the state tax "is collected, often along with an additional local realty transfer tax, by county Recorders of Deeds", who remit the Commonwealth's 1 percent to the Department. Article 373 makes the Recorder the collection agent for the City's tax, and the tax is "payable at the earlier of the time the document is presented for recording or within 30 days of acceptance of such document".
Are transfers between family members excluded?
Many are. Section 373.04(f) excludes transfers between husband and wife; between people previously married to each other who have since divorced, where the property was acquired before the final decree; between parent and child or the spouse of that child; between siblings or the spouse of a sibling; and between a grandparent and grandchild or the spouse of that grandchild. There is a clawback: "a subsequent transfer by the grantee within one year shall be subject to tax as if the grantor were making such transfer." Our note on buying a home from a family member covers the financing side.
Do I have to prove an exclusion applies?
Generally yes, through a statement of value. The ordinance requires that to exercise an exclusion "the true, full and complete value of the transfer shall be shown on the statement of value", and the Pennsylvania Realty Transfer Tax Statement of Value may be used. Section 373.11 carves out an exception: that requirement does not apply to excludable transfers that are exempt "based on family relationship".
Is recording my mortgage a taxable transfer?
No. The ordinance's definition of "document" in § 373.01(c) expressly excludes "wills, mortgages, deeds of trust or other instruments of like character given as security for a debt and deeds of release thereof to the debtor". The transfer tax attaches to the conveyance of title, not to the security instrument. Land contracts where legal title does not pass until the consideration is paid are also outside the definition, "unless the consideration is payable over a period of time exceeding 30 years".
What if I am buying from a government body or at a sheriff sale?
A government body's own exemption does not help the other side. Section 373.03 exempts the United States, the Commonwealth and their instrumentalities, agencies and political subdivisions, but states that "The exemption of such governmental bodies shall not, however, relieve any other party to a transaction from liability for the tax." On a judicial sale, § 373.09 gives the tax priority out of the proceeds ahead of most other claims except the state tax — and provides that "If the proceeds of the sale are insufficient to pay the entire tax herein imposed, the purchaser shall be liable for the remaining tax."
What happens if the tax is underpaid?
The City authorises the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue to determine, collect and enforce the tax, interest and penalties, with interest at 10% per annum. The assessment window under § 373.13 is three years from the recording of the document, extending to six years "If the taxpayer underpays the correct amount of the tax by 25% or more", and with no time limit where part of the underpayment is due to fraud or "an undisclosed, intentional disregard of rules and regulations".
Can the transfer tax be negotiated as part of the deal?
Who bears it, yes — that is what § 91.111(b) contemplates when it says the duty may be discharged "as they agree". How it is structured is worth thinking about alongside other concessions, because a seller contribution toward closing costs and a reduction in price do not have identical effects on a loan. Our note on seller credits versus price reductions sets out the difference.